Key Points
-
S&P Global maintained USDt’s stability assessment at 5, its lowest rating, citing growing exposure to higher-risk reserve assets.
-
Riskier holdings accounted for 28% of USDT in circulation as of September 30, compared with 24% a year earlier.
-
Tether disputed S&P’s methodology, while reserve disclosures showed approximately $7.95 billion in excess assets over liabilities.
S&P Global Ratings has maintained Tether’s USDt stablecoin at the lowest level on its stability assessment scale, citing increased exposure to riskier reserve assets and concerns surrounding transparency, regulatory safeguards and asset segregation.
In its November 18 report, S&P assigned USDt a score of 5, categorized as weak, unchanged from its November 2025 assessment. The rating reflects concerns that a decline in the value of certain reserve assets could undermine the stablecoin’s ability to maintain its dollar peg.
As of September 30, higher-risk holdings, including gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans and corporate bonds, represented approximately 28% of USDt in circulation, up from 24% a year earlier.
S&P warned that a significant decline in the value of these assets could potentially leave USDT undercollateralized.
Tether Challenges S&P’s Methodology
Tether pushed back against the assessment, arguing that the criticism reflects weaknesses in S&P’s framework rather than problems with its reserves.
The company invoked The Big Short, the film depicting the 2008 financial crisis, in its response to the ratings agency, suggesting that traditional financial risk assessments have their own historical shortcomings.
Tether’s September 30 reserve report, attested by BDO, showed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities. The difference represented roughly $7.95 billion in excess assets.
S&P said it identified additional weaknesses but could not lower the assessment further because 5 is the lowest score available on its scale.
Regulatory Oversight and Reserve Segregation Concerns
S&P also questioned the regulatory framework overseeing Tether in El Salvador, where the company relocated in January 2025.
The National Commission of Digital Assets, or CNAD, requires 70% of reserves to be held in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days. However, S&P described the framework as broad, allowing relatively higher-risk assets such as Bitcoin, gold and loans to qualify within the reserve structure.
The ratings agency also highlighted the absence of a requirement to segregate reserve assets. Unlike certain regulatory expectations in the United States and Europe, the framework does not require publicly documented segregation of reserves.
S&P said the lack of publicly available information regarding segregation leaves uncertainty about how reserve assets are protected from broader corporate risks.
Audit Transparency Remains a Point of Debate
Tether highlighted its 2025 financial audit, which received an unqualified opinion from KPMG in August 2026. The company described the audit as its first full independent audit and said it supported its financial statements.
However, S&P noted that the audited statements and auditor’s report had not been publicly released, limiting its ability to independently evaluate the underlying information.
The agency also raised concerns that Tether’s reserve reports do not identify the custodians and counterparties holding its assets. Additionally, its attestations are published quarterly, compared with monthly reporting generally provided by other stablecoin issuers.
Market Stability Versus Reserve Risk
Despite maintaining its lowest assessment, S&P acknowledged that Tether has demonstrated a good history of price stability, particularly over the past 12 months.
The disagreement highlights the distinction between a stablecoin’s historical ability to maintain its peg and the underlying composition, transparency and liquidity of its reserves.
As stablecoin regulation continues to evolve, investors and market participants are likely to focus increasingly on reserve quality, independent disclosure, asset segregation and the ability to withstand adverse market conditions. For Tether, maintaining confidence may depend not only on reserve levels but also on how clearly those reserves can be independently verified.
Comparison, examination, and analysis between investment houses
Leave your details, and an expert from our team will get back to you as soon as possible