SKN | Tom Lee says BitMine’s $6B ether paper loss is “by design”

A drawdown the company expected

Tom Lee is pushing back against criticism surrounding BitMine Immersion’s growing unrealized losses, arguing that the more than $6 billion paper drawdown on its ether holdings is not a failure, but an intentional outcome of the company’s strategy.

In a series of posts on X, Lee said BitMine was never designed to manage short-term volatility. Instead, it is structured to mirror and ultimately outperform the price of Ethereum over a full market cycle, even if that means absorbing large unrealized losses during downturns.

Index-style exposure, not tactical trading

Lee compared BitMine’s approach to an index-style product rather than an actively traded portfolio. When markets fall, index funds post losses, he argued, and BitMine should be viewed through the same lens.

With crypto markets broadly under pressure, Lee said it is inevitable that ETH-linked balance sheets will show red ink. In his words, paper losses are “not a bug — it’s a feature” of maintaining long-duration exposure to a core asset during a down cycle.

That framing comes as ether’s slide has reduced the value of BitMine’s holdings to roughly $9.6 billion, down from nearly $14 billion at the October peak. The company currently holds about 4.24 million ETH, making it one of the largest ether treasury vehicles in the market.

Accumulation continues despite volatility

Rather than slowing purchases, BitMine has continued to accumulate ETH, adding more than 40,000 coins shortly before the latest leg lower. The firm has consistently described itself as an ether treasury company, prioritizing accumulation and staking yield over price timing.

That approach mirrors strategies used by some bitcoin-focused treasury firms, which accept sharp interim drawdowns as the cost of maintaining long-term exposure. The difference, however, is scale. With millions of ETH on its balance sheet, even modest price moves translate into multibillion-dollar swings in reported value.

Staking income offers limited cushion

BitMine has previously estimated annual staking revenue of roughly $164 million, providing a steady stream of income tied to its ETH holdings. While meaningful, that yield does little to offset the impact of sharp market-wide corrections, particularly during periods of thin liquidity and forced deleveraging across derivatives markets.

Lee has acknowledged those risks, warning that crypto may still be working through a broader deleveraging phase that could weigh on prices into early 2026.

Long-term conviction unchanged

Despite the near-term pressure, Lee’s comments underscore that BitMine’s thesis remains intact. The firm is positioning itself not as a short-term trade, but as a leveraged expression of long-term belief in Ethereum’s role in global finance.

As Lee summed it up, volatility is the price of conviction. From BitMine’s perspective, the current losses are not a signal to retreat, but confirmation that the strategy is behaving exactly as intended in a down market.